UPDATED: Christmas 2010 eBook Buying Guide

Based on what I’m seeing in search terms that lead to this blog, I’m making this post a sticky until December 24th.

This has also been updated a third time, to put the two Viewsonic tablets in the Absolutely Avoid category.

Fourth and final update, for the two Archos tablets.

Recommended, in order of best value:

1) Apple iPad: Via available free apps, it can be any eBook device now: a Kindle, a Barnes & Noble Nook, a Kobo Reader, a Sony Reader; plus there’s Apple’s own iBookstore (which I do not recommend due to lock-in DRM). Plus it can do Google Books PDFs right out of the box. And with Bluefire Reader it can now do public library eBook loans too. Due to size and weight, this is more of an at-home device.

2) Barnes & Noble NookColor: If you have the tech chops to root this device — or have the patience to wait for a no-brainer way of rooting — this can be an excellent Android tablet at a bargain price. Its 1024×600 screen trumps the Archos 70’s 800×480 screen. It also features iPad-like touch responsiveness. Rooting does not remove or otherwise disturb the built-in Barnes & Noble functionality (which I do not recommend using at all due to variant DRM). It enables apps to be added, so aside from being a Nook, it can also be a Kobo Reader, a Kindle, a Sony Reader (still forthcoming), and do ePub eBooks via Aldiko.

3) Apple iPod Touch: As above, but bring-everywhere portability, although Google Books PDF viewing does not work properly, so don’t get it if you want that bit. Some people claim reading off an LCD is tiring. Just turn down the damn backlight. I read eBooks on my LCD-based LifeDrive all the time.

4) Amazon Kindle: The hardware can be frustrating, but it has the most books to buy and the most new books for free. It cannot do public library eBook borrowing, however.

5) Sony Reader Pocket Touch PRS-350: It’s small and light and fast and can do “classic” Adobe DRM ePub, which is required for public library eBook borrowing. It lacks wireless capability, which is sad.

6) Kobo Reader WiFi: A device with WiFi for just $129 is a steal. Mind you, the WiFi is just for shopping at Kobo/Borders, there’s no browsing the web, and having to use one button for the on-screen keyboard to buy books is slow, but it can do “classic” Adobe DRM for public library borrowing. It’s an inexpensive entry into eBooks with a reputable device.

7) Sony Reader Touch Edition PRS-650: It’s a larger version of the Pocket with two storage slots and audio-playing ability added in. It too lacks wireless capability.

8) Archos 70 Internet Tablet: I hesitate to recommend this due to its 800 x 480 screen. Really, once you’ve seen the sharpness of the NookColor screen, everything else seems backward and crude. However, this is another Android tablet from a reputable (although tempermental) company. Since it runs Android, it can also be a Nook, a Kobo Reader, a Kindle, a Sony Reader (still forthcoming), and do ePub eBooks via Aldiko. (Note: make sure you’re buying the Archos 70 Internet Tablet and not the must-avoid Archos 7 Home Tablet!)

9) Sony Reader Daily Touch PRS-950: Even larger than the other two models, but it has WiFi and 3G for buying books through Sony’s eBookstore. WiFi — but not 3G — lets you view the web with its included browser.

10) Samung Galaxy Tab: It’s not an iPad, it’s a giant Android phone. Using free apps, it can be a Kindle, a Nook, a Kobo Reader, a Sony Reader, and it can use the Aldiko eBook reading software too. This is very expensive off-contract and not worth it at that price but it’s the first generally-available Android tablet out there right now that works well.

Not recommended:

1) Barnes & Noble Nook eInk: The hardware is great but the DRM is lock-in to Barnes & Noble, which I think is a huge, huge mistake.

2) Archos 101 Tablet: There are reports of screen issues. I can’t recommend this in good conscience due to that. If you’re up to taking a risk, it’s otherwise a damn good tablet and would fall second in the list, right after the iPad, if everyone could be guaranteed of getting a good screen. Its placement here as Not Recommended is strictly due to Archos taking its eye off Quality Control and nothing else.

If you can’t do any better:

1) Sony Pocket Edition PRS-300
2) Sony Touch Edition PRS-600

Both of those are on sale at low-low prices. The first is too slow, the second has a screen that can be problematic. But they are a low-cost entry into eBooks — and well-built devices — and can do public library loans.

I have not yet been able to try any of these for myself and none of the reviews out there answer any of the questions I have, so I can’t say anything about them right now other than they might be worth buying.

Absolutely avoid, in no order:

1) Pandigital Novel
2) Cruz Reader
3) Cruz Tablet
4) Augen The Book
5) Augen Gentouch tablet
6) The Literati
7) Aluratek Libre
8) ECTACO jetBook
9) ViewSonic Open Book
10) ViewSonic 7 Tablet
11) ViewSonic 10 Tablet

— and anything else on sale in a drugstore, discount store, or a big-box department store that isn’t listed under Recommended. There are many, many devices flooding the market and they are very cheaply made and are buggy. None of them are any bargains and they will give you grief and probably break within a year or less of use. They make you think you’re getting into eBooks, but all they’re doing is taking you for a sucker and ruining eBooks for you.

3 Comments

Filed under eInk Devices, Other Hardware

3 responses to “UPDATED: Christmas 2010 eBook Buying Guide

  1. Pingback: Recommended Read: eBook Buying Guide « Fliplog – Publish your eBooks with iPad, iPhone & Android applications

  2. iPad is the Rosetta Stone of ereaders. My favorite ereader, in spite of its pdf issues is my iphone, which I use to read insane amounts of material, bookish and otherwise. Re: PDF–there is a pdf to epub converter out there that I’ve used to make pdfs readable on iphone/ipod touch. But I haven’t used it on a very long document.

  3. Pingback: How Barnes & Noble Can Help Kill Itself

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s